Here at Milligan’s Gander Hill Farm we have learned the hard way to try and work with mother nature instead trying to work against her. Take for instance our pond. We have tried to have our pond be clear and full of bass, crappie, blue gill, and channel cat fish, but that hasn’t worked out. Mother nature thinks we should have a Bullhead catfish pond, so thats what we are going to go along with because just like with my wife, mother nature usually gets her way anyway no matter how hard you try otherwise.
With the flooding that brings in the Bullheads to our pond and the river otters eating our other game fish, we come the the conclusion its a waste of time and money trying to keep our pond stocked with the other game fish.
After careful thought I think our pond is better suited for the catfish. It is only about 8ft deep at its deepest and the bullhead can live with less oxygen when the pond freezes in the winter. They also breed easily in a farm pond and you can always catch bullheads anytime of day or night. Even though the bullhead doesn’t have a very good reputation with most game fisherman they are very good to eat especially in the spring and fall when water temperatures are cooler.

The species of Bullhead we have is the yellow Bullhead catfish. Most pond owners don’t want the bullhead to get into their pond because they breed very fast and can quickly take over a pond. Also with the bottom feeding habit of this fish it keeps the mud on a pond stirred up which causes water clarity issues.
Bullheads eat just about anything, insects, tad poles, vegetation, snails, minnows, dead fish, marshmallows, pieces of hot dogs, worms, chicken livers, shrimp and catfish stink baits. We use night crawlers to catch ours. Right now there are so many bullheads in our pond, you can cast out a line and catch one in just a few minutes so it’s a very good fish to introduce fishing to new comers to the sport. The only trouble is there are so many fish that they have eaten up most of the natural food in the pond and are not very big because of it. Our solution is to start feeding the bullheads with a commercial floating game fish food that some catfish farmers use.
We have also just stocked our pond with 5 pounds of fathead minnows. The bullheads and other game fish will eat these too.

The fathead minnow is a prolific breeder and will start breeding once the water temperature reaches 64 degrees F and will keep breeding until water temperatures drop below 64 degrees come fall.
Like most things here on our farm we don’t have any experience with this and are learning as we go. I would like to hear from others who have had similar experiences with their farm pond. If any body would like to catch a mess of catfish, come on down, ya hear!
It sounds like you’ve made a wise decision! Glad you can enjoy the catfish!
Thanks Susan, how have you been? I haven’t seen any of your posts lately.
I haven’t been posting, Gordon. I need to. Last year was a drought and it was rough. Not much positive to say, so I didn’t say anything! 🙂 But I do need to share the good things happening this year!
I grew up catching bullheads on my grandparents farm. Always enjoyed eating them too!
Thanks Mathew, this was the first fish I learned to fish for and have always enjoyed eating them too.
When I was raised up in central Lllinois I love to catch and set bull heads. We finally go the addition done and now we are moving around cabinets to get a dishwasher in. Also where the window was the dry wall is being fixed. Enjoy your pond.
Thanks Rick, glad to hear your project is almost done. I need to do another post myself on the stuff we got done lately.
Hi Gordon. I’ve only just gotten to reading this post. As someone who knows absolutely nothing about Fish, I found it really interesting. Pond ? your place really does have it all. I see you haven’t posted for a while, so hope you’re well ? Steve
Could you e-mail me to discuss
your ongoing Bullhead catfish
raising? I have been experimenting with same for a number of years
Agrofor@msn.com